For the perfect words
As you know, losing a tooth — especially the first one — can be scary, a little painful, suspenseful, and sometimes exciting. Whatever the circumstances, it's a very personal event and an important step in a child's development.
We've gathered a variety of tips, message examples, and even the words some parents use for “the talk” — for when your child is finally ready to know the truth about the tradition you've kept alive for so long.
Thank you for letting us help celebrate this moment.
A few gentle tips
If your child is nervous about a stranger visiting at night, a gentle introduction message from the Tooth Fairy herself — explaining she's kind, quiet, and only ever brings good things — can ease that specific worry.
If your child just seems generally anxious, choose the softest, most validating tone. Sometimes the message isn't about teeth at all — it's about letting your child know their feelings are normal and they're not alone.
You know your child best. Mix and match phrases from different messages, or add a personal detail — a nickname, an inside joke, something they did that day — to make it feel like it could only have been written for them.
33 written just for this moment
Every message uses [Name] where your child's name will appear — it's filled in automatically when you pick one.
“Hi [Name]. I want to tell you a secret — I don't just have wings, I fly with Fairy Dust. And Fairy Dust is made from beautiful teeth just like yours. I magically turn precious teeth into Gold Fairy Dust, so I can fly to the next kid. So your tooth turns into Fairy Fuel. I left some behind, so you can touch it. Sweet dreams, brave one.”
“Hi [Name], thank you very much for your beautiful tooth. I promise to put it to good use. Have you ever wondered how I fly? It's not just wings — it's Fairy Dust. And Fairy Dust is made from one thing only: the teeth kids like you shared with me. Every tooth I collect becomes a little dust of my own kind of magic — gold and glittering, just enough to carry me to the next sleeping child who needs a visit. Tonight, your tooth became part of that magic. Somewhere out there, it's helping me fly to the next child, just like your tooth helped me reach you.”
“Hi [Name] — my newest tooth-losing friend, welcome to a very old club. Every tooth I collect gets added to a moonlit vault that goes back further than your grandparents, and further than theirs. Someday you'll tell your own kids about tonight — about the tooth under the pillow and the glitter you found in the morning. For now, just know this: you did something big by being brave, and I noticed. Sweet dreams, brave one.”
“Hi [Name], what a beautiful tooth! Thank you soooo much. I want to tell you a secret about how I get around. It's not just wings — it's Fairy Dust, and Fairy Dust is made from teeth just like yours. Every tooth I collect turns into a little bit of gold magic that helps me fly to the next child who's ready for a visit. So tonight, your tooth isn't just going with me — it's becoming part of how I do my job. I sprinkled a little dust on your pillow so you'd have your own piece of the magic too. Thank you, [Name]. You helped me fly.”
“I've been collecting teeth for a very long time, [Name], and I can tell — this one belonged to someone kind. Keep being you. Sweet dreams.”
“Growing up means letting go of little things to make room for bigger ones. You did that so well tonight, [Name]. I'm proud of you.”
“Your mom and dad told me how proud they are of you, [Name]. I already knew — I could feel it the moment I found your tooth. Sweet dreams, brave one.”
“One tooth down, [Name], and a whole lot of smiles still ahead. Sweet dreams, brave one.”
“Hi [Name]. I heard you were a bit worried about your tooth wiggling loose — and that's a completely normal thing to feel. Even the bravest kids get a little nervous. But I want you to know: it didn't hurt you — it just means your body is doing exactly what it's supposed to do, making room for your grown-up smile. You handled it so well. I'm proud of you.”
“Hi [Name]. I know it felt strange to lose something that's been part of you your whole life. But here's the truth — you're not losing anything that matters. You're trading it in for something even better. The real you, your laugh, your ideas, your kindness — none of that changes. Your smile just gets an upgrade.”
“[Name], thank you very much for sharing your tooth with me. I know losing a tooth can be a little scary. But remember, it's something your body accomplished. You grew that tooth, you used it well, and now you've earned your next one. That's not scary. That's impressive.”
“Hi [Name]! Thank you soooo much for your beautiful tooth. I know you might have been a little scared when it fell out, but that's just how tiny mighty teeth say goodbye — it's supposed to happen, and it means you're growing up strong. You did great.”
“Dear [Name], I know losing a tooth can feel a little strange — one moment it's there, wiggling away, and the next it's gone. But I promise, this is one of the best kinds of grown-up steps there is. Nothing to be scared of, only something to be proud of. Sleep tight. Sweet dreams, brave one.”
“Hi [Name]! You looked so sweet sleeping in your cute bed. This is my first time collecting a tooth from you, and I have to say — worth the wait. I've heard about you from the other fairies for a while now, and I finally get to see what all the fuss is about. Welcome to the club. There's no secret handshake, but there is glitter and a special gift, so that's basically the same thing.”
“So… this is it, huh, [Name]? Your very last baby tooth. I'll be honest — I got a little sentimental packing this one up. I remember the first one like it was yesterday (it basically was, fairy years are weird). You've officially graduated from baby teeth. No more visits from me after this, but don't worry — I'm told the memories stick around a lot longer than I do. It's been an honor. Truly. Sniff.”
“Well, kid, you got me. This is officially my last pickup from you, [Name] — you're all grown up now, at least in the tooth department. I've collected a lot of teeth in my time, but yours were always some of my favorites to visit. Thanks for believing in me for as long as you did. It meant more than you know.”
“Last tooth. Last visit. I wanted to say thank you, [Name] — for every tooth, every note, every time you tried to stay awake to catch me. You did great. I'm proud of you.”
“Dear [Name], I flew 3,847 miles to get your tooth — and let me tell you, it was worth every wingbeat. Top-shelf quality. Keep 'em coming!”
“Confession, [Name] — I may have done a little happy dance in your room. Your tooth is going straight to my collection. VIP shelf.”
“[Name], I heard you were SO brave getting this tooth out that even the dentist gave you a high five. That's rare. I'm impressed, and I don't impress easy.”
“Word around the pillow is you've got more wiggly teeth coming, [Name]. Don't spend this all in one place — I'll be back.”
“[Name], PS — sorry about the glitter. Fairy dust doesn't come in 'subtle.'”
“Tooth received. Payment issued. This message will not self-destruct, [Name], but my magic dust might make your pillow sparkle for a few days. You're welcome.”
“Do you have any idea how many teeth I collect a night, [Name]? Yours was still my favorite. Don't tell the others.”
“Rumor has it you checked under your pillow four times before bed, [Name]. I was watching. Very suspenseful for both of us.”
“WOW! [Name], your tooth was SO shiny I almost tripped over a cloud looking at it.”
“[Name], I did a happy dance so big I lost one of my own shoes. Worth it.”
“This tooth is officially in my top-ten collection of the year, [Name]. And I've seen a LOT of teeth.”
“Four hundred years on the job, [Name], and I still get excited about a good tooth. Yours was top-tier.”
“I don't usually admit this to humans, [Name], but you have very good tooth hygiene. Keep it up.”
“I know you're too old for this, [Name]. I'm not. See you next tooth.”
“I've been informed by several older kids that I'm 'not real.' Weird thing to say to someone currently in your room. Sweet dreams, [Name].”
“[Name], I'll keep showing up as long as you keep leaving teeth under there. No questions asked. That's the deal.”
For the day they ask
At some point your child will be old enough to wonder — and eventually to know. When that day comes, you might not have the words ready. Here's a starting point.
“I bet you're wondering why we didn't just tell you sooner. Here's the truth: being a kid who believes in magic is one of the best things in the whole world, and it doesn't last very long. We wanted you to get to have that feeling — the excitement, the wondering, the checking under your pillow — for as long as we possibly could. That wasn't us tricking you. That was us trying to give you something special before you had to grow up and know how everything works. You're old enough now to know the truth. But you're not too old for magic. You just get to make it for other people now instead.”
“We didn't tell you because being little and believing in magic is amazing, and it goes by fast. We wanted you to have that for as long as we could give it to you. Now that you know, here's the secret: you get to be the magic for someone else someday.”
“I think it's time you knew something: I've had a lot of help over the years. Every parent who ever kept this tradition alive — including yours — is part of my team. They're the ones who really make the magic happen, night after night, tooth after tooth. I just get the credit. You're old enough now to be let in on it. Welcome to the secret. Guard it well.”
Ready to make one?
Pick a message you love — we'll set the wizard to Type mode with your choice already filled in.
✦ Create Yours·$19.99